Is AI Writing the Final Chapter of Software Copyright?

Dr. Jonathan A. Platt

If artificial intelligence writes your computer code, who owns the copyright? Perhaps nobody. And that could be a rather significant problem for the software industry.

In a new paper, The End of Software Copyright, Stanford Law School Professor Mark A. Lemley suggests that AI-generated computer code may spell the end of software copyright as we know it. How could that happen?

According to Professor Lemley, when AI generates computer code, one of three things occurs. First, the AI may reproduce proprietary code from its training materials, potentially resulting in copyright infringement. Worse yet, incorporating infringing code into a larger program may jeopardize copyright protection for the programmer's own contributions. See 17 USC 103(a).

Second, the AI may reproduce open-source code. Certain open-source licenses require derivative works to be distributed under the same license, potentially undermining a company's ability to keep its software proprietary.

Third, the AI may generate entirely new code that does not copy protected material.

The problem that these paths raise is with authorship. In Thaler v. Perlmutter, 130 F.4th 1039 (D.C. Cir. 2025), the D.C. Circuit held that copyright protection requires human authorship. Thus, code generated entirely by AI may not be copyrightable, regardless of its commercial value.

The programmer supplied the idea, but copyright does not protect ideas. See 17 USC 102(b). The AI supplied the expression, but AI-generated expression is not copyrightable under current U.S. law.

And therein lies the rub.

But could patent law save the day? Unfortunately, patent law presents its own difficulties, in terms of inventorship. In Thaler v. Vidal, 43 F.4th 1207 (Fed. Cir. 2022), the Federal Circuit held that an inventor must be a natural person. Although AI-assisted inventions may qualify for patent protection, AI itself cannot be an inventor.

In addition, software implementing an abstract idea may encounter patent-eligibility problems under Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International, 573 U.S. 208 (2014), and its extensive and far-reaching prodigy.

Trade secret protection offers another possibility, but only while the information remains secret.

So what happens next? Professor Lemley envisions four possible futures: 1) freely available software; 2) widespread copyright litigation; 3) legislation extending copyright to AI-generated code; or 4) an industry that simply muddles through.

In that last scenario, companies may employ programmers to modify AI-generated code primarily to establish copyright ownership. Talk about the tail wagging the dog.

Of course, human-authored software remains copyrightable, and AI-assisted programs may contain protectable human contributions. Nevertheless, Professor Lemley's broader observation is difficult to ignore.

Perhaps the end of software copyright is not quite upon us. But its future may be considerably less secure than (at least some) software developers assume.

Previous
Previous

Congratulations to Amulya Pattali and Philip Kwon on Their Admission to the Ohio Bar

Next
Next

Not exactly a fairy-tale ending, but good news regarding the RAPUNZEL trademark